Measures to assess commonly experienced symptoms for people with dementia in long-term care settings: a systematic reviewReportar como inadecuado

Measures to assess commonly experienced symptoms for people with dementia in long-term care settings: a systematic review - Descarga este documento en PDF. Documentación en PDF para descargar gratis. Disponible también para leer online.

BMC Medicine

, 14:38

First Online: 26 February 2016Received: 18 November 2015Accepted: 15 February 2016DOI: 10.1186-s12916-016-0582-x

Cite this article as: Ellis-Smith, C., Evans, C.J., Bone, A.E. et al. BMC Med 2016 14: 38. doi:10.1186-s12916-016-0582-x


BackgroundHigh symptom burden is common in long-term care residents with dementia and results in distress and behavioral challenges if undetected. Physicians may have limited time to regularly examine all residents, particularly those unable to self-report, and may rely on reports from caregivers who are frequently in a good position to detect symptoms quickly. We aimed to identify proxy-completed assessment measures of symptoms experienced by people with dementia, and critically appraise the psychometric properties and applicability for use in long-term care settings by caregivers.

MethodsWe searched Medline, EMBASE, PsycINFO, CINAHL and ASSIA from inception to 23 June 2015, supplemented by citation and reference searches. The search strategy used a combination of terms: dementia OR long-term care AND assessment AND symptoms e.g. pain. Studies were included if they evaluated psychometric properties of proxy-completed symptom assessment measures for people with dementia in any setting or those of mixed cognitive abilities residing in long-term care settings. Measures were included if they did not require clinical training, and used proxy-observed behaviors to support assessment in verbally compromised people with dementia. Data were extracted on study setting and sample, measurement properties and psychometric properties. Measures were independently evaluated by two investigators using quality criteria for measurement properties, and evaluated for clinical applicability in long-term settings.

ResultsOf the 19,942 studies identified, 40 studies evaluating 32 measures assessing pain n = 12, oral health n = 2, multiple neuropsychiatric symptoms n = 2, depression n = 8, anxiety n = 2, psychological wellbeing n = 4, and discomfort n = 2 were included. The majority of studies 31-40 were conducted in long-term care settings although none of the neuropsychiatric or anxiety measures were validated in this setting. The pain assessments, PAINAD and PACSLAC had the strongest psychometric evidence. The oral health, discomfort, and three psychological wellbeing measures were validated in this setting but require further psychometric evaluation. Depression measures were poor at detecting depression in this population. All measures require further investigation into agreement, responsiveness and interpretability.

ConclusionsMeasures for pain are best developed for this population and setting. All other measures require further validation. A multi-symptom measure to support comprehensive assessment and monitoring in this population is required.

KeywordsDementia Long-term care Palliative care Review Symptom assessment AbbreviationsAARSApparent Affect Rating Scale

APSAbbey Pain Scale

AERApparent Emotion Rating

BOHSEBrief Oral Health Status Examination

CNPIChecklist of Nonverbal Pain Behaviors

CSDDCornell Scale for Depression in Dementia

CS-GDSCollateral Source Geriatric Depression Scale

DBSDiscomfort Behavior Scale

DS-DATDiscomfort Scale for patients with Dementia of Alzheimer’s Type

ICCIntraclass correlation coefficient

NOPPAINNon-communicative Patient’s Pain Assessment Instrument

NPI-QNeuropsychiatric Inventory-Questionnaire

OHATOral Health Assessment Tool

PACSLACPain Assessment Checklist for Seniors with Limited Ability to Communicate

PADEPain Assessment for the Dementing Elderly

PAINADPain Assessment in Advanced Dementia

PBOICIEPain Behaviors for Osteoarthritis Instrument for Cognitively Impaired Elders

PGCARSPhiladelphia Geriatric Center Affect Rating Scale

RDOSRespiratory Distress Observation Scale

Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article doi:10.1186-s12916-016-0582-x contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Download fulltext PDF

Autor: Clare Ellis-Smith - Catherine J. Evans - Anna E. Bone - Lesley A. Henson - Mendwas Dzingina - Pauline M. Kane - Irene J


Documentos relacionados