Conceptualizing childhood health problems using survey data: a comparison of key indicatorsReportar como inadecuado

Conceptualizing childhood health problems using survey data: a comparison of key indicators - Descarga este documento en PDF. Documentación en PDF para descargar gratis. Disponible también para leer online.

BMC Pediatrics

, 7:40

First Online: 05 December 2007Received: 27 February 2007Accepted: 05 December 2007


BackgroundMany definitions are being used to conceptualize child health problems. With survey data, commonly used indicators for identifying children with health problems have included chronic condition checklists, measures of activity limitations, elevated service use, and health utility thresholds. This study compares these different indicators in terms of the prevalence rates elicited, and in terms of how the subgroups identified differ.

MethodsSecondary data analyses used data from the National Longitudinal Survey of Children and Youth, which surveyed a nationally representative sample of Canadian children n = 13,790. Descriptive analyses compared healthy children to those with health problems, as classified by any of the key indicators. Additional analyses examined differences between subgroups of children captured by a single indicator and those described as having health problems by multiple indicators.

ResultsThis study demonstrates that children captured by any of the indicators had poorer health than healthy children, despite the fact that over half the sample 52.2% was characterized as having a health problem by at least one indicator. Rates of child ill health differed by indicator; 5.6% had an activity limitation, 9.2% exhibited a severe health difficulty, 31.7% reported a chronic condition, and 36.6% had elevated service use. Further, the four key indicators captured different types of children. Indicator groupings differed on child and socio-demographic factors. Compared to children identified by more than one indicator, those identified only by the severe health difficulty indicator displayed more cognitive problems p < 0.0001, those identified only by the chronic condition checklist had a greater likelihood of reporting allergies or asthma p < 0.0001, and those identified as having elevated service use only were more affluent p = 0.01 and showed better overall health p < 0.0001. Children identified by only a single indicator were less likely to have serious health problems than those identified by two or more indicators.

ConclusionWe provide information useful to researchers when selecting indicators from survey data to identify children with health problems. Researchers and policy makers need to be aware of the impact of such definitions on prevalence rates as well as on the composition of children classified as being in poor health.

AbbreviationsHUIHealth Utilities Index

NLSCYNational Longitudinal Survey of Children and Youth

PMKPerson most knowledgeable

CSHCNChildren with special health care needs

SHDSevere health difficulties

CBCLChild behaviour checklist

QuICCC-RQuestionnaire for Identifying Children with Chronic Conditions – Revised

ICFInternational Classification of Functioning.

Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article doi:10.1186-1471-2431-7-40 contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Download fulltext PDF

Autor: Dafna E Kohen - Jamie C Brehaut - Rochelle E Garner - Anton R Miller - Lucyna M Lach - Anne F Klassen - Peter L Rose


Documentos relacionados