Asthma self-assessment in a Medicaid populationReport as inadecuate

Asthma self-assessment in a Medicaid population - Download this document for free, or read online. Document in PDF available to download.

BMC Public Health

, 9:244

First Online: 16 July 2009Received: 15 April 2009Accepted: 16 July 2009DOI: 10.1186-1471-2458-9-244

Cite this article as: Wu, A.C., Glauber, J., Gay, C. et al. BMC Public Health 2009 9: 244. doi:10.1186-1471-2458-9-244


BackgroundSelf-assessment of symptoms by patients with chronic conditions is an important element of disease management. A recent study in a commercially-insured population found that patients who received automated telephone calls for asthma self-assessment felt they benefitted from the calls. Few studies have evaluated the effectiveness of disease self-assessment in Medicaid populations. The goals of this study were to: 1 assess the feasibility of asthma self-assessment in a population predominantly insured by Medicaid, 2 study whether adding a gift card incentive increased completion of the self-assessment survey, and 3 evaluate how the self-assessment affected processes and outcomes of care.

MethodsWe studied adults and children aged 4 years and older who were insured by a Medicaid-focused managed care organization MCO in a pre- and post-intervention study. During the pre-incentive period, patients with computerized utilization data that met specific criteria for problematic asthma control were mailed the Asthma Control Test ACT, a self-assessment survey, and asked to return it to the MCO. During the intervention period, patients were offered a $20 gift card for returning the completed ACT to the MCO. To evaluate clinical outcomes, we used computerized claims data to assess the number of hospitalization visits and emergency department visits experienced in the 3 months after receiving the ACT. To evaluate whether the self-management intervention improved processes of care, we conducted telephone interviews with patients who returned or did not return the ACT by mail.

ResultsDuring the pre-incentive period, 1183 patients were identified as having problems with asthma control; 25 2.0% of these returned the ACT to the MCO. In contrast, during the incentive period, 1612 patients were identified as having problems with asthma control and 87 5.4% of these returned the ACT to the MCO p < 0.0001. Of all 95 ACTs that were returned, 87% had a score of 19 or less, which suggested poor asthma control.

During the 3 months after they received the ACT, patients who completed it had similar numbers of outpatient visits, emergency department visits, and hospitalizations for asthma as patients who did not complete the ACT. We completed interviews with 95 patients, including 28 who had completed the ACT and 67 who had not. Based on an ACT administered at the time of the interview, patients who had previously returned the ACT to the MCO had asthma control similar to those who had not mean scores of 14.2 vs. 14.6, p = 0.70. Patients had similar rates of contacting their providers within the past 2 months whether they had completed the mailed ACT or not 71% vs. 76%, p = 0.57.

ConclusionMailing asthma self-assessment surveys to patients with poorly controlled asthma was not associated with better asthma-associated outcomes or processes of care in the Medicaid population studied. Adding a gift card incentive did not meaningfully increase response rates. Asthma disease management programs for Medicaid populations will most likely need to involve alternative strategies for engaging patients and their providers in managing their conditions.

Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article doi:10.1186-1471-2458-9-244 contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Download fulltext PDF

Author: Ann C Wu - James Glauber - Charlene Gay - Tracy A Lieu


Related documents